A Study in Lavender: Queering Sherlock Holmes by Joseph R. G. DeMarco Review
Whenever I read a new collection of Sherlock Holmes pastiches, there are two aspects I hope to find. First that all the stories are well written and enjoyable. And that the stories provide new insights into Holmes and Watson or that a new twist will be provided ino their adventures.
In both categories, "A Study in Lavender" succeeds. Too often an editor places the best story at the beginning of a collection and the rest are go downhill from there. With this collection, all the stories provide a good read. As as for a twist, exploring the Victorian world of Sherlock Holmes where characters are homosexual - gay or lesbian, certainly provides new ways to understand Holmes and Watson as they either see these qualities within themselves are within their clients.
There is no overt sexual scenes in this anthology, instead the characters "gayness" provide new problems and crimes that must be dealt with. In some stories, it is Holmes or Watson or both that must deal with their hidden homosexuality.
For example, in "The Adventure of the Poesy Ring" by Elka Cloke, two men, two lovers, shared twin rings and now one is dead and his ring has vanished. While Holmes and Dr. Watson investigate the disappearance of the lover's ring, Watson recognizes his own inner love For Holmes and wonders if Holmes shares those feelings. As if doing a scientific experiment, Watson kisses Holmes and then must face the possibility that their friendship is over...
In "The Case of the Wounded Heart" by Rajan Khanna, Inspector Lestrade's police career is threatened as he investigates a murder that seems to involve another policeman - his lover.
And sometimes it is the villain who must come to terms, or not, of his homosexuality. In the story, "Whom God Destroys" by Ruth Sims, Sir Author Conan Doyle, unwittingly harbors a serial killer...
Each story in this collection works at the level of mystery and in revealing the difficulties of being "gay" in a Victorian Society...
Overall Rating (based on customer reviews): 4.5 out of 5 stars
The specs of 'A Study in Lavender: Queering Sherlock Holmes' are:
Publisher: Lethe Press (2011-06-05)
Product Dimensions: 9x5.9x0.9 inches
Shipping Weight: 1.2 pounds
Here are some more REAL customer reviews:
"Fun Read But No Sex Please, We're British"
I have to admit, this is a fun read. Somewhere between a good published pastiche short story collection and well-written fan fiction. I wasn't sure what to expect, thought there'd be more erotica, alright, porn. Slightly disappointed my more... Read more
"Sherlockian mysteries of alternative lifestyles"
It is not my practice to review Sherlockian fiction of such a specialized nature, however, I purchased this book because I collect Sherlockian pastiches and felt I needed to add the stories to my database. I made the mistake of reading the first and was... Read more
I was surprised by how much I liked this book. I read the introduction, and the editor pointed out specific points in the Canon that seemed to say that Doyle thought Holmes and Watson might be lovers. I figured that if Doyle hinted at it, I might as well... Read more
A Study in Lavender: Queering Sherlock Holmes at the best price available today.
Other Joseph R. G. DeMarco Books For Sale
A Study in Lavender: Queering Sherlock Holmes by Joseph R. G. DeMarco Review related articles from the blogosphere...
There is a surprising lack of Holmes-Watson romance in this given the subtext in the books, which was a little disappointing. However, the stories that the authors chose to tell instead were interesting and the characters appealing so overall it didn't matter.
eBook Addict: A Study in Lavender: Queering Sherlock Holmes
Study in Lavender, the Holmes universe is queered and ten authors have devised stories in which Holmes and Watson are lovers, or investigate mysteries of inverts hidden from the laws and cultures of the Victorian era; ...
2011 11 22 4 A Study in Lavender
Scholars and fans have been arguing about the implications of queerness in the Holmes canon for a long time—it’s a popular topic. Two men in an intense emotional relationship, living together, sharing spaces and finances and their lives; well. It’s suggestive, and it’s intriguing. Both of the most recent big-name interpretations of the Holmes stories—the Robert Downey, Jr. movie and the BBC’s delightful Sherlock—have played with the intensity of the relationship between Holmes and Watson, explored it and made suggestions about it.
This book seeks to do the same, but much more openly, as well as exploring the possibilities of other queer folks whose lives may have intersected that of the Great Detective.
A Study in Lavender: Queering Sherlock Holmes ed. by Joseph ...
Study in Lavender, edited by Joseph DeMarco, is a 2011 anthology from Lethe Press that features a variety of queer-themed stories set in the Sherlock Holmes canon(s); some are (obviously) about Holmes and Watson's ...
A Study in Lavender « Weightless Books
Includes work by J.R. Campbell, Elka Cloke, William P. Coleman, Michael G. Cornelius, Lyn C.A. Gardner, Rajan Khanna, Vincent Kovar, Stephen Osborne, Katie Raynes, and Ruth Sims.
What other characters from English literature have captivated hearts and minds as thoroughly as Sherlock Holmes and his loyal companion John Watson? M.